Is this due to the controversy she’s been in with Japanese netizens?
jrebel_0 on
The official explanation is that she’s sitting out due to poor health
One does have to wonder if that’s a convenient excuse given the whole situation that’s been unfolding since the groups participation was announced (both the lamp issue and rising political tensions)
chae_lil on
Actually, it is very possible that health is also involved considering Ning has been unwell for weeks now and literally yesterday said she hasn’t recovered.
But also, I understand why she’s not performing given situation concerning her and entire group safety.
I hope the 3 members will finish this performance peacefully so this could be put to rest finally after months.
wizxxleo on
I think this is more about the geopolitical situation between China and Japan than the lamp issue
friedriceforbrunch on
I’m surprised that a lot of MYs on twt actually believe she’s sitting out due to “poor health”.
healthyscalpsforall on
So it looks like Ningning has been sick since the beginning of the month… I think this may just be coincidental. And honestly, it’s probably for the best that she sit this one out.
Hope she recovers soon!
Fine_Childhood_6391 on
Japanese fans were bullying Ningning nonstop, but K-pop related subreddits, as always, have been tight-lipped about the issue. If Korean fans were like that, they would have attacked Knetz in all sorts of ways, saying that they were the worst and that Korea’s cancel culture was the problem.
Late_Art9758 on

LongConsideration662 on
It’s good that she is sitting this one out and sm can absolutely do nothing in this situation, it’s more than kpop. The tensions between japan and china have been at an all time high due to right wing japanese pm taikichi’s remarks about supporting taiwan in case china invades. A japanese singer performing in china was also removed from the stage.
1lookwhiplash on
I saw her latest IG post and she’s looking pretty damn hot for being in poor health 😂
11 Comments
Is this due to the controversy she’s been in with Japanese netizens?
The official explanation is that she’s sitting out due to poor health
One does have to wonder if that’s a convenient excuse given the whole situation that’s been unfolding since the groups participation was announced (both the lamp issue and rising political tensions)
Actually, it is very possible that health is also involved considering Ning has been unwell for weeks now and literally yesterday said she hasn’t recovered.
But also, I understand why she’s not performing given situation concerning her and entire group safety.
I hope the 3 members will finish this performance peacefully so this could be put to rest finally after months.
I think this is more about the geopolitical situation between China and Japan than the lamp issue
I’m surprised that a lot of MYs on twt actually believe she’s sitting out due to “poor health”.
So it looks like Ningning has been sick since the beginning of the month… I think this may just be coincidental. And honestly, it’s probably for the best that she sit this one out.
Hope she recovers soon!
Japanese fans were bullying Ningning nonstop, but K-pop related subreddits, as always, have been tight-lipped about the issue. If Korean fans were like that, they would have attacked Knetz in all sorts of ways, saying that they were the worst and that Korea’s cancel culture was the problem.

It’s good that she is sitting this one out and sm can absolutely do nothing in this situation, it’s more than kpop. The tensions between japan and china have been at an all time high due to right wing japanese pm taikichi’s remarks about supporting taiwan in case china invades. A japanese singer performing in china was also removed from the stage.
I saw her latest IG post and she’s looking pretty damn hot for being in poor health 😂
china is not a real country.